Cutting remarks

At the beginning of this month we passed our first anniversary of living in Scotland, and over the past year I’ve thought a good deal about what it means to be the gardener of a garden you don’t own and ultimately have no rights over. Though we have no rights, we do have a responsibility, outlined in our tenancy agreement, to keep the garden looking as well as it did when we moved in. And in effect, do I have no rights over the rose I planted, or the hellibore, or the crocuses? Could I take them with me if I wanted to?*IMG_0309

Gardening your landlord’s garden means you can’t rearrange things (very much). You have to look after the beastly rhododendrons as though they were your own and feed them with their beastly ericaceous squirt, and you can’t dig up and replace the sickly roses in case they have sentimental value, and you can’t chuck out the concrete slabs or relocate the disproportionately large shed that some half-wit built slap in the sunniest spot of the garden. And even if the landlord said, yes, please do anything you like to the garden, you can’t because it means spending hundreds on a garden that is not yours.

On the other hand, gardening your landlord’s garden means not having to make decisions, learning to make the best of the situation you’re stuck with, delighting over the unexpected springing up of plants that previous tenants have planted, imagining the delight of future tenants when the bulbs and plants that you planted push through the soil, and finally the freedom to make mistakes and have a practice run before you get a garden of your own.


Which leads me to… I hardly dare say it. In fact, I’d better keep quiet for fear of tempting fate. Only I’ve been taking cuttings (these photos are of cuttings of this purple clematis and also some of Left Neighbour’s clematisIMG_0305; the copper tape supposedly stops the snails) just in case I might need to populate a purely hypothetical garden belonging to a purely hypothetical flat that The Brazilian and I may or may not have had an offer accepted on. Hypothetically.


*An academic question because I don’t want to; they belong where they’ve been planted. I once read a forum thread on Money Saving Expert about gardeners who were selling up, asking if it was unethical to remove and take with them all the expensive plants they’d planted in the garden. Imagine! It made me sick to think of the poor buyers turning up all delighted and excited about the mature garden they’d bought along with the house, then getting there to find acres of bare earth.

4 thoughts on “Cutting remarks

  1. I think that’s a fair exchange! Maintaining the Landlord’s garden in return for some cuttings! A win-win situation! Good luck with the cuttings. – and the hypothetical new garden 😉

  2. Under English law the plants are part of the land, I think, so if you plant a rose bush it becomes the landlord’s property. I think. However there is an escape clause to this, called “intention”. If you didn’t intend it to be part of the land it might not be. All clear so far? This is what we have lawyers for.
    However you are not in England, I’ve no idea what the Scots law is. I expect the bottom line is to leave the garden tidy and stocked with at least what was there when you arrived. Few things are more delightful than the first year of owning a garden and watching what comes up, I hope the hypothetical new tenants will appreciate your plantings. If they are into minimalist chic they may even like the white bulbs more than you did.
    As for plants in a garden one sells, the question isn’t one of ethics. The buyer is entitled to find the garden more or less as he viewed it. If the seller intends to remove some, or all (but tricky, that) of the plants he should inform the buyer that they are not part of the deal before the contracts are signed. He might be well advised to remove the plants he wants to take before the property is viewed. When we moved here the previous owners were very careful to tell us that the sundial would be going with them.
    Taking cuttings is the proper thing to do. Your clematis plants look nice and healthy, I hope they strike for you – it’s a lovely flower with that white stripe on the deep purple.
    Guess what? your orchid that is a different sort from the others is flowering. So are some of the others. The orchids were not watered for several weeks and it has clearly done them a power of good.

  3. The taking up of a garden is quite often the case here when one sells their house. Many people move in to find all the lovely plants gone. GET IT IN WRITING THAT THE GARDEN STAYS AS IS!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s